Reginelli's Pizzeria Reviews

I called Reginelli’s with a quick question about my order, and they picked up faster than I expected. The person I spoke with was friendly, didn’t make me feel rushed, and got everything handled right away. If you’re local and ever need to check on an order, I’d say just give them a call instead of stressing about it. It was simple, easy, and a nice change from places that leave you on hold forever.

I stopped by because the location was really convenient for me, and getting there was easy enough. Even parking wasn’t the headache I was expecting, so at first I thought it was going to be a smooth visit. But once I was there, nothing really made the trip feel worthwhile. It wasn’t terrible, just kind of average, and I kept thinking the best part was just how easy it was to get to. If I’m already nearby I might consider it, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to come back.

The pizza was warm and tasted fine, so no complaints there. But the pickup took longer than they told me, and that’s on whoever was managing the orders that night. I planned around the time they gave me and still ended up waiting. Not a terrible experience, just not one I’d call great either.

My snap judgment? This place is an easy win for a family dinner. The staff were really patient with my kids, and the whole night just felt simple and stress-free

Ordered dinner through reginellis and it was easy to use. The menu loaded fine, checkout wasn’t confusing at all, and I got the confirmation right away. Food was good when it arrived, but delivery was about 10 mins later than the time they gave me. Not a huge deal tbh, I’d still order again.

I went to Reginelli’s last weekend, based on that visit, it left a good impression. The place looked clean overall, tables were wiped down, the floor seemed well kept, and even the bathroom was decent. The only thing I noticed was one trash bin that looked a little too full, but it didn’t really take away from the meal. Since my most recent experience was a good one, I’d give it 4 stars

As someone who’s picky about baked goods, I loved these. The edges were nice and crispy, but the middle stayed soft and chewy, basically exactly how I want them

The plates were really filling. I almost feel like they could’ve warned me how much food I was getting, because I definitely didn’t expect to leave that full.

The pizza tasted really good, and I really liked the crust too. My only complaint is that it could’ve used a bit more sauce, which feels like a preventable issue. Still enjoyed it overall.

I ordered Reginelli’s through the site, the pizza was good. The veggies actually tasted fresh, not like they’d been sitting around all day, and the cheese had that nice melty thing going on.

I’ll admit I’m a little loyal to my usual pizza spot, so I was kind of comparing it the whole time. The only thing that threw me off was the crust being a bit softer than I normally like, but overall it was a solid order and I’d probably get it again.

I ordered from reginellis.com and, just assuming this might be typical with delivery, the food showed up fine overall, but the packaging was kind of uneven. The box was a little bent, and one side had sauce on it, so I ended up with a small mess when I opened everything.
Nothing was actually ruined and the food still tasted good, so it wasn’t a huge deal. I just kind of expected it to be packed a bit cleaner and neater, especially if this is how they usually send orders out. Not terrible, but definitely something they could improve next time.

The food showed up hot and tasted really fresh, so I was happy with it. No complaints at all. Seriously, I opened the bag and was like, okay wow, they actually got this right.

The food was fine, nothing I’d complain about, but the staff kind of made the whole visit feel awkward. I’m probably a little sensitive to service stuff because I really notice when a place feels welcoming, and this didn’t. No one was outright rude, but they were short with us and seemed annoyed when we asked a simple question. Maybe they were just slammed or having an off day, but it still didn’t leave the best impression. I might give it another shot sometime, but I’m definitely not in a hurry

Stopped by Reginelli’s for dinner it was a really nice little spot. The place wasn’t super loud, but it still had that kinda busy pizza place energy, which I liked. Staff was relaxed and friendly, tables were clean, and the warm lighting made it feel easy to just sit and hang out for a bit. Nothing fancy or over the top, just comfy and welcoming. Def a good place for a casual meal with friends or family, I’d go back.

I ordered from Reginelli’s the other night and had to ask a few questions because of a dairy allergy. The person helping me seemed familiar with what was in the food, and they still went back to double-check with the kitchen, which I really appreciated. It made me feel a lot better about ordering. The food ended up being really good too. Only downside was that it took a bit longer than I expected, so I’d give it 4 stars overall...

i’ve been here a few times now and the food has been good every single visit so far

The food was totally fine, so that part wasn’t really the issue. But I emailed them about a charge that didn’t look right, and it took days to get a reply. When they finally responded, it was super short and didn’t really explain anything. I was left kind of confused, like… was anyone actually looking into it or not? Just felt like they didn’t really want to help fix the problem.

I really like Reginelli’s because the menu has a little bit of everything, which is so nice. Pizza, salads, pasta, sandwiches, and even options my kids are happy with. It makes ordering way easier when everyone in the house wants something different. Kind of a low-key lifesaver.

I’ve ordered from Reginelli's Pizzeria a couple times now, and overall I think the prices are fair for what you get. The portions have been decent, and the pizza tastes fresh, not the best I’ve ever had, but definitely solid for an easy weeknight dinner. The delivery fee does make it feel like less of a deal if you’re only ordering a small amount, so I usually add a little extra to make it feel worth it. One thing that was kind of disappointing is that when I had a question about my order, I felt a bit dismissed and like they were just trying to move on quickly. Still, the food has been good enough that I’d probably order again.

Everything showed up correct, which was a relief. I’ve had too many orders where something is missing, something is wrong, or something just doesn’t match what I picked, so I was expecting another headache. But nope, no mix-ups, no missing items, no wrong stuff. Finally, it came the way it was supposed to.